July 2004
Three parishes in the diocese closing or in transition
Gene Young
Managing Editor
Two parishes in the diocese have closed and another is in the process of transitioning from a parish to a small Catholic community.
Bishop Robert J. Carlson recently announced that Ss. Cyrillus and Methodius Parish, Vodnany and Sacred Heart Parish, Chelsea would close effective July 1.
Ss. Cyrillus and Methodius served as a parish of the diocese of 118 years while Sacred Heart served for 94 years as a parish of the diocese.
“It is always a very, very painful process because something that was alive is dying,” the bishop said.
“I know this is a very sad thing,” the bishop said. “It’s a death. Sometimes it is more than 100 years of faith...I find very few people who would disagree with the process except when it is their parish.”
The bishop also announced that St. Catherine Parish, Oldham, is exploring and considering the possibility of becoming a small Catholic community. That means the parish no longer has the celebration of Mass and the members of the parish will decide over the next several months what they want to do...turn their parish into a small Catholic community or close.
The bishop said that other diocesan parishes also face similar decisions down the road. In several cases, two diocesan parishes will merge and become one.
Bishop Carlson said he saw some surprises this spring in some places that were facing transition. “In a few places where they have chosen to become small Catholic communities, the experience has not always been positive,” he said. “Some people have suggested it might have been better if the parish just closed because they have exhausted all their resources and still face questions of how to care for their cemetery and things like that.”
The bishop added that in a small Catholic community there is not a priest necessarily looking after them and people can fall through the cracks. If a parish closes, the congregation is transferred to another priest and is spiritually cared for that way.
The moves help the diocese avoid creating an undue burden for people in traveling to church. They strengthen existing parishes and foster those congregations that had a strong experience of parish community.
The bishop said the diocese will continue to examine all of the diocese’s parishes, especially where populations are declining and the community and the parish congregation are shrinking. “If a parish is declining, and we are looking at all the parishes with 50 or fewer families, we have to ask, what can we realistically staff with the number of priests we have available and how can we have the strongest parishes possible?,” the bishop said.
Members of the diocesan personnel board met with the parish communities that are declining.
The parish closings are part of a process that began back in 1994 when the diocese began looking at parish life. “We said at that time, if we experience the ordination of four priests a year, on average, we could keep even the smallest community open, but that is not happening,” the bishop said. “At the same time, we have the second youngest average age of priests of all ten dioceses in the province.”
“As you talk to the priests, they all agree that something has to happen but when you go to a particular parish, it is sometimes very difficult for them to see that they might be the one,” the bishop said.
He added the process is likely to be with us for the next several years.
The process of parish closings, though, is not new to the Diocese of Sioux Falls. In the history of the diocese, 147 parishes have already closed. They closed because “the railroad stopped going there or the people moved or there was a loss of jobs,” he added.
In some places in the diocese, the community is actually seeing job growth. Bishop Carlson pointed to Huron where new processing plants are opening up and attracting new residents. The diocese is sensitive to that kind of development and asks itself how will it serve the new residents of a community and their faith needs.
The bishop said the diocese continues to have a good number of priests for a diocese of 125,000 people. “We have 88 diocesan priests and several order priests,” he said. But he added that the orders and religious communities who have sent priests to serve in our diocese are seeing declining numbers and are not able to staff parishes here the way they once did.
The Franciscans are no longer able to staff a priest in four diocesan parishes and the priests of Blue Cloud Abbey, Marvin, will only staff two parishes in the year ahead.

 
July 2004 Articles
Our Bishop Writes
This Catholic's Life
Fr. Stan Says

New Vicar General
Three Closing Parishes
Broom Tree's First Retreat
Presentations/Nuclear
Winds of Storm and Spirit
Ordination Jubilee
Euthanasia is not Negotiable
Priest Appointments

Bulletin Archives
2004 Bulletins
2005 Bulletins
2006 Bulletins
2007 Bulletins
2008 Bulletins